I sent the following email to the Vermont House Education Committee. And I must add each of them has been most friendly to me....
Thank you for letting me share some of my thoughts on education with you.
The one-room schools of Vermont, which most of my contemporaries here attended and even taught, were able to offer very individualized attention to the pupil. But even more important was the inter-generational inter-action, older children helping teacher with the younger.
The very ‘advanced’ school to which I went in New Jersey was already shoveling children though the school system in an age group, aimed at teaching the ‘average’. I remember still some of the people in my class, but I cannot recall one other person in that school.
The people I know in Vermont all came out of their school system ready to be responsible functioning members of the community. They are the ones keeping Town Meetings and the notion of civic responsibility alive.
I see a strong correlation between this inter-generational experience and today’s young people’s lack of community involvement..
Today’s educational philosophy is too abstract, especially in its insistence that college is the preferred goal. A week or so ago we had our first major snow storm and power outages as a result. It was very clear that any line-worker was worth more to us than any quantity of CEO’s, MBA’s, computer programmers, or NASA engineers.
Finally I am deeply disturbed by how easily we have turned the mental and physical health of our children over to the marketing practices of any business which wants to make money off them.
I do hope with all my heart that you will give your support to some sort of civic education.
I see this being accomplished with the gift of the State of a book like the one I showed all of you, containing the Declaration of Independence, the Federal Constitution, and Vermont’s two State Constitutions, both the present and the first, which was of itself an extraordinary document, to every sixth grader at the start of the school year. The accompanying course would mandate a read-through of each document and testing only of the actual words, no interpretations.
I see sixth graders generally moaning and groaning at the imposition of such a course, but out of this group will come our town clerks, select board members, local and federal legislators, lawyers, as well as citizens like myself, who will indeed value such a course more the longer they live.
Thank you again for taking time out of your busy lives to read this. I hope it has contributed something for you! Sincerely, Pat Hejny
Chairman Howard
So Howard Dean is now Chairman of the Democratic National Party.
I thought that when he was a presidential candidate, he represented the party’s one real chance at an election victory. Now that he has this position I see him once again as the only chance the Democrats have to make themselves into a cohesive party which is truly distinctive from the present Bush Republicans.
Bush Republicans have clearly defined themselves as the party for the stock market/corporate economy and for the privatization of all community/governmental functions..
It was not Dean’s ’organizational’ skills nor his use of internet fund raising that were his strengths as a presidential candidate..
He appealed to two groups of people, neither of which contained many wealthy individuals, but both of which had many individuals ready to contribute to someone who offered them a solution and some hope.
The first group was the many young adults in this country who dislike Bush Republicans but feel no strong sympathy with the traditional worker/labor union orientation of Democrats.
The second group was people like myself, what I call real Republicans, passionately devoted to upholding the Constitution and its protection of the individual and each state against any tyranny proposed against us. We can no longer support the aims of the Bush Republican ‘business community’, and until Howard Dean began talking, felt ourselves disenfranchised by both parties.
If he is allowed to make the positions he held as a candidate the positions of the Party, the Democrats have a chance to become viable once again.
But Democrats have first got to rid themselves of all of their closet Republicans, the business allied so-called Centrists like Joe Lieberman and Bill Clinton and Senator Kerry. As much corporation sympathetic legislation was passed in the Clinton administration as in any of the Republican administrations before or after. And certainly Kerry was far too much a part of the Washington scene to be able to hold onto many of the people who were ready to support Dean.
And they had better come to understand that the Republican business community has as its mantra the power of marketing. Take any product, idea, program, or fact, its worth or its truth is unimportant. Its image and the way that image is marketed is what will make the sale. Business learned this with the great success it had in TV advertising. The whole Iraq war was marketed to us and without, as is only too obvious now, any real thought given to the practical realities of securing a successful outcome.
Whether or not Dean himself was consciously using a marketing approach in the way he presented his positions, his forceful manner and his constant repetition of a simple statement matched anything the Bush Republicans could put forward.
Will the Democrats be able to rise again but as a new party, truly representing all of the opposition to the Bush Republicans that is out there right now? The next two years will give the answer....
February 13, 2005 in Miscellaneous commentary (rants) | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)